Re: [Paddlewise] Eco Challenge - some answers

From: Robert J. Nagle <nagle_at_tammy.harvard.edu>
Date: Tue, 21 Apr 1998 06:01:42 -0400
Jackie Fenton <jackie_at_intelenet.net> wrote:

jackie> I was wondering, though, how they missed that a participant could not 
jackie> swim and one participant had never paddled a canoe in his life.  Did 

There is no swim test required.  However one rule says, in its
entirety, "as a condition of entry, participants are expected to be
able to swim".
In Queensland, the only paddling test was a self rescue in a pool.

jackie> Thanks for that clarification.  I heard on an earlier report that one
jackie> of the teams that participated in '97 (Killroy) was not accepted
jackie> into this year's race because the organizers believed them not to have 
jackie> enough experience.  

Every year, the standards are raised.  There have not been many
opportunities for teams to race and acquire demonstrable experience.
But fortunately that situation is changing.

jackie> I also noted that there was a blackout called by the organizers for
jackie> the whitewater rafting (if teams did not reach the put-in for the
jackie> whitewater rafting in time to finish that portion before dark, then
jackie> they were required to wait until the following day).  However, the
jackie> canoeing portion was allowed to continue in the dark.

The rafting was the only section that had a "dark zone".  The kayaking
and canoeing both went on all round the clock.  In past years we've
done class 3 drops in Canadian canoes at 1 AM (no moon) - now that was
stupid. 

jackie> I did like that, for the most part, the organizer wanted the teams to
jackie> make their own choices.  One team chose not to rapel and instead took
jackie> what they thought would be a shorter route over a hill which was
jackie> reported as dangerous due to the loose rocks and steep climb which
jackie> the participants did not expect.  Teams were allowed to choose whether
jackie> to rapel and swim the distance across the river to climb the other 
jackie> side. 

The TV show was very unlcear about this so you may have drawn improper
conclusions.  In fact, all of the rope sections were compulsory (and
the white water swim).  The segment on Pure Energy scrambling up a
crumbly face occurred *after* they had ascended the ropes after the ww
swim.  There was still about 100-200 feet from the top of the ropes to the
canyon rim - that's where they became a little exposed.  What they
were scrambling over was pure powder.

But yes (to tie things vaguely back to Paddlewise charter) judgement
is a significant factor in adventure racing. The most significant
probably has to do with sleep - when to, how much to.  But it enters
into a thousand decisions a day - drink this water or not, route
finding (on water and land), picking lines (on water and land), etc.

jackie> btw, I would love to see any comments you might have about the Texas
jackie> Water Safari.  And good luck! :-)

I refuse to comment on the ground that I might incriminate myself (I'm
dealing with Texans - they're alreay hoisting my petard).


RN
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Robert J. Nagle					 http://yuri.harvard.edu/~nagle

***************************************************************************
PaddleWise Paddling Mailing List
Submissions:     paddlewise_at_lists.intelenet.net
Subscriptions:   paddlewise-request_at_lists.intelenet.net
Website:         http://www.gasp-seakayak.net/paddlewise/
***************************************************************************
Received on Tue Apr 21 1998 - 03:12:56 PDT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0 : Thu Aug 21 2025 - 16:29:56 PDT