Re: [Paddlewise] HX150S VHF

Mark wrote, "I know the Standard HX350S VHF radio has often been recommended here on Paddlewise.  The HX150S model is some $130 less in price.  Has anyone had any
experience with this model.  I do not mind giving up some "ease of use" features but are there any "safety" related differences with this model(range, water resistance, reliability, etc)."

The big thing to consider in any radio which does not meet the "submersible" standards --- one meter deep water for a half hour --- is the fact that you're depending on the sustained integrity of a plastic bag to protect your means of communication.  (Sorta like depending on the integrity of a thin latex dry suit seal when you're out on a major trip in January --- but maybe we shouldn't go there right now .....)  If you're comfortable with that condition, and you replace the bag regularly and have the confidence that the bag will not fail in any conditions or under any damage that might occur to it in a "worst case" scenario, then the 150 is probably a good bet.  

I won't take that bet, personally, because I don't want to assume that, if I've been knocked out of my boat and really need that radio in an emergency, I'm not also in condtions which could fairly easily compromise the bag, as well.  That's why I paid the premium for the 350.  It's not bagged, it's used hard --- especially last weekend! --- and it gets wet if I work an assisted rescue drill or roll.  It still works fine.  

One other issue to consider --- don't know the 150, but the 350 has an automatic NOAA weather alert function --- the tone you get prior to an emergency weather broadcast --- even if you're not listening to or scanning the WX band.  More than a nice to have, in my opinion.

Jack Martin
***************************************************************************
PaddleWise Paddling Mailing List - All postings copyright the author and not
to be reproduced outside PaddleWise without author's permission
Submissions:     paddlewise_at_lists.intelenet.net
Subscriptions:   paddlewise-request_at_lists.intelenet.net
Website:         http://www.paddlewise.net/
***************************************************************************