Re: [Paddlewise] Interesting accident case in Sea Kayaker

From: Jochen Grikschat <grikschat_at_surfeu.de>
Date: Fri, 20 Apr 2001 12:08:55 +0200
I tried to tell you this story a few weeks ago under those general rescue
storys.

Aug. 98 Reimer Siemers died after several hours on hypothermia nearby
several North Friesian Islands.
I know the guy who tell him, that a wing paddle is an "ideal" choice. But
nobody told him, that he should go out alone and test this paddle there for
FIRST time. The man was paddling only for few years, aged over 50 and got
teachers profession. Maybe a problem on its own (oversized-selfconsciouness,
>nothing against teachers<). He had trained the self-rescue by paddle float
ONLY under calm (flat water) conditions and was unable to do the roll
anyway.
That it was the wing paddle, causes him to capsize is a easy thought and
also mine, but nobody was there. So its only a "shot in the fog"- thought.

Iīm using 3rd year a wing paddle and have done the re-entry (by float) WITH
these (extreme) wing paddle. No problem Ralph! But you have to pay
attention, for sure. And I got a spare paddle with me, everytime I use the
wing paddle. Not normal, but for me.

The thing with the ship is unbelieveable... And the Skippers is still in
problems. He still might lose his captn license.

BUT, Mr. Siemers GOT signal flares (donīt know with ones), BUT they still
layed by a friend. He forgot them there after a tour...
With any visible red or orange distress signal, the ship hadnīt driven away.
But so, the skipper only hear that 2 passengers see a man in water, waving
with hand or a paddle, and he interpreted it as a "Hello, nice day" sign.
That they couldnīt see him, was more than clear. It was the fastetst ship in
that area and the first binoculars take part a few minutes AFTER the short
sightning. Nobody would have seen him after a few minutes by over 20-25
knots and 4 Bft wind and over 3 ft. waves! Thatīs one reason the skipper was
sentenced on not-given-help.

Was a really sad incident and the first dead kayaker for the SaU
(saltwaterunion germany).

The dead man got the first step (out of 2 ...) of SaU-certification.
Should be an incident to learn and to talk about intensively. But the almost
only man, talking about this incident do this very early and in a unpopular
style. So, the "thinking" section of the SaU shot bundles of flame on him
and his style of writing. Nothing had changed since them.
The "Experts" say, there system is proved and okay. No necessarry
modification is needed.
The joke is, this first step, called the A-level, is almost the normally
known "sea-proficiency". We know, the britains got 3 or 4 (??) further
levels, the SaU only one real further one. The B-level, which is needed to
lead a group (on SaU trips). Thats all! Okay, the C-level, but thats only
for those leaders, doing enough trips a years...

Much to do here in Germany. But which way?? Within the SaU or the official
canoe federation you canīt build up those structures, like the britains got.

Unbelieveable but typical human.

bye from germany

Jochen Grikschat

***************************************************************************
PaddleWise Paddling Mailing List - Any opinions or suggestions expressed
here are solely those of the writer(s). You must assume the entire
responsibility for reliance upon them. All postings copyright the author.
Submissions:     PaddleWise_at_PaddleWise.net
Subscriptions:   PaddleWise-request_at_PaddleWise.net
Website:         http://www.paddlewise.net/
***************************************************************************
Received on Fri Apr 20 2001 - 03:14:11 PDT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0 : Thu Aug 21 2025 - 16:30:41 PDT