Re: [Paddlewise] British Heavies Crumple

From: Matt Broze <mkayaks_at_oz.net>
Date: Thu, 17 Apr 2003 02:00:17 -0700
Peter Treby wrote:

>>>>>>>>Just checking some advertised weights for British "Heavies":

Pintail, 50 lbs, or 22.7 kg.
Romany Explorer 56 lbs, or 25.4 kg.
Compared with:
CD Gulfstream, glass 51 lbs, 23.1 kg
[55.3]
CD Caribou S, glass, 50 lbs 22.7 kg
QCC Q600x, glass, 50 lbs, 22.7 kg
Seaward Endeavour, 55 lbs, 24.9 kg
[57.5]
Dagger Cortez, glass, 60 lbs, 27.2 kg
and plastic boats:
Prijon Seayak, 58 lbs, 26 kg.
[67]
Perception Carolina 64 lbs, 29 kg (w/o rudder)

Comparisons and generalizations are odious, so I won't go on, but the
British boats don't appear to be generally heavier, if at all.<<<<<<<<<

I wouldn't pay too much attention to advertised weights. I've weighed kayaks
that were 15 pounds more than advertised and heard of one that was
advertised at 56 pounds actually weighing in at 76. In the case I heard
about, I had told a customer that the kayak model he was considering would
weigh about 56 pounds with the construction and features and seat he wanted.
He responded with (or something very like): "The (a plastic kayak) I have
now weighs 56 pounds and I can hardly lift it." I asked if he had actually
weighed his kayak or that was the advertised weigh. He said: "advertised". I
asked him to weigh himself on his bathroom scale when he got home and then
pick up the kayak and subtract his weight from the scales reading. He called
later and said "76 pounds". Some companies are pretty good about getting the
advertised weight close to what the reality will be but others play very
fast and loose with this dimension. Sea Kayaker actually weighs the kayaks
(but be sure to check if the tested kayak sent to them wasn't Kevlar or
Graphite--as it often is) before believing that that is what the weight of
standard glass lay-up of the kayak you buy will be.

The Sea Kayaker weights for the kayaks on your above list that they weighed
are in the brackets [  ] I added to the advertised weights listed above. I
wish I had actual weights for all the kayaks I've kept other dimensions for
but that would be too hard to test and I can't trust the listed advertised
weights so I don't bother keeping track of that dimension (which is also
subject to variation for many reasons-see our websites "FAQ's"). You can
find the weights of most of the kayaks Sea Kayaker weighed during testing
them by opening the (.XLS) drag spreadsheet (MS Excel) from the "downloads"
section of our website and subtracting 250 pounds from the "Disp.lb."
(weight) column (for the kayaks in the archived data section of the
spreadsheet). I'm sorry I don't have a way of quickly knowing which were
Kevlar or graphite models (careful reading of the original article usually
indicates the lay-up). I should note that because that will also make the
drag results look a little better for those kayaks as well.

I have not heard of any composite kayaks crumpling from air pressure before.
I'd be interested in seeing pictures or getting a good description of where
and what of the damage. Black can get pretty hot in the sun and the resin
would be a little more flexible when it was hot. A minute hole through the
middle of the bulkhead would be the easiest solution. I imagine Stan at GRO
will make sure future kayaks leaving his store will have that or another way
to relieve the pressure differences. I can't imagine a Pygmy's hatch seal
would be so good as to allow a big pressure differential to build up. Years
ago an early Sea Kayaker magazine reported several VCP hatch lids popped off
when the day heated up during a kayak testing trip.

Matt Broze
http://www.marinerkayaks.com


***************************************************************************
PaddleWise Paddling Mailing List - Any opinions or suggestions expressed
here are solely those of the writer(s). You must assume the entire
responsibility for reliance upon them. All postings copyright the author.
Submissions:     PaddleWise_at_PaddleWise.net
Subscriptions:   PaddleWise-request_at_PaddleWise.net
Website:         http://www.paddlewise.net/
***************************************************************************
Received on Thu Apr 17 2003 - 02:02:39 PDT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0 : Thu Aug 21 2025 - 16:31:05 PDT