Re: [Paddlewise] Roll-aid

I have also considered purchasing a Roll-Aid - again, as someone without a 
bomb-proof roll.  I have several solo/assisted wet recoveries down pat in 
varying conditions BUT I look at the Roll-Aid as a yet another redundant 
backup.  I see recoveries as something that involve a whole toolkit of 
tricks.  Try the roll....did it work?  great!  Didn't work? then what is 
your next option?  Wet exit?  Is the Roll-Aid better than this?

I would not suggest someone buy this aid and then not practice any other 
methods or not attempt to learn to roll or improve the one they have BUT I 
think as a last ditch back-up prior to wet exiting - I don't see a problem 
with it.  From what I can tell, the aid has much more buoyancy than a 
paddlefloat.  And it has a cord on it (not exposed until deployed) that 
allows you to tether it after deploying it - keeping it ready for a 
subsequent capsize (although I'm not a fan of things on cords hanging 
around my cockpit).

If someone has $135 to spend and is willing to faithfully install it on 
their deck (useless if not) and is still willing to explore other recovery 
methods - then I say by all means, order away.  I wouldn't dismiss this as 
an option for some people.  Again, back to having a bigger toolkit with 
more options.  I wouldn't discourage anyone from expanding their options - 
if they have the $.

My guess is that someone with even a hint of understanding of the mechanics 
of a roll should be able to roll up with this aid using one hand.  I would 
not advocate letting go of your paddle - I'd rather wet exit and climb back 
in than risk becoming separated from my paddle - even though I have a spare 
(usually stowed on the back deck which isn't the handiest place if you are 
still in your cockpit in challenging conditions).

Of course, I should point out that I'm coming at this from the perspective 
of an inland water paddler - no surf zone here.  Most capsizes occur while 
I'm doing something - like shooting pics or grabbing a snack or 
??  Instances that most likely make for a less than organized roll attempt :o)

Of course all the usual disclaimers apply - no connections to company or 
products mentioned...
K
***************************************************************************
PaddleWise Paddling Mailing List - Any opinions or suggestions expressed
here are solely those of the writer(s). You must assume the entire
responsibility for reliance upon them. All postings copyright the author.
Submissions:     PaddleWise_at_PaddleWise.net
Subscriptions:   PaddleWise-request_at_PaddleWise.net
Website:         http://www.paddlewise.net/
***************************************************************************