Re: [Paddlewise] PFD Required??

I've actually lost track of why we're on the PFD thread, however I'd 
like to add some thoughts (which I hope don't sound too preachy). 

Last fall I wrote a piece regarding the need for certain equipment when 
a kayaker participates in a swim support.  In part, I said: 

>>>> 
> Therefore, I recommend that swim race support kayakers: 
> 
> 1. Always wear a PFD.  If a swimmer is in distress, you may need to 
> lend immediate aide and not think to put one on or waste time doing 
> so.  If you are dealing with someone in the water, things can happen 
> that would cause you to be in the water too.  Wearing a PFD will help 
> you continue to provide aide while in the water and make your rescue 
> easier for the rest of us. 
> 2. Always use a spray skirt.  If you are helping a swimmer in the 
> water, you may need to lean your boat while doing so.  The last thing 
> you need is to be scooping water into your cockpit. 
> 3. Insure that your boat has adequate floatation.  If you go for a 
> swim while helping a swimmer, it will give you both something to hold 
> on to until more help arrives.  It will also help other kayakers to 
> help you get back in your boat. 
> 4. Carry a spare PFD under a deck bungee.  If a swimmer gets in 
> trouble, it is much better to toss a PFD to them then to have them 
> grab onto your boat possibly causing an upset. 
> 
> In essence, what I am preaching here is to have floatation for you, 
> your boat and for a swimmer.  I think it makes good sense.    
> 
<<<< 

I think the arguments I made for a kayaker aiding a swimmer would stand 
for a kayaker aiding another kayaker (who could very easily become a 
swimmer).  I don't, however, carry a spare PFD on non swim support 
paddles. 

I have much sympathy with the "Live free or die" people and have argued 
my right to motorcycle without a helmet. In the spirit of that then, I 
could even admit that I would support the notion that paddling solo 
without a PFD is the same and should be left to the individual.  
However, paddling with others is different.  Absolutely none of the 
other people I have ever met paddling have given me the impression that 
they would not aid another paddler in need.  It therefore makes sense to
me to be ready immediately to give other that aid.  As an added bonus, 
you provide safety for yourself. 

Just my ramblings, 

Bill Leonhardt 

ps   BTW, I find that wearing a PFD is like wearing a seat belt in the 
car.  I feel really weird if it's not there.
***************************************************************************
PaddleWise Paddling Mailing List - All postings copyright the author and not
to be reproduced outside PaddleWise without author's permission
Submissions:     paddlewise_at_lists.intelenet.net
Subscriptions:   paddlewise-request_at_lists.intelenet.net
Website:         http://www.paddlewise.net/
***************************************************************************