Re: [Paddlewise] Question for Doug Lloyd

>> While my perspective might not be worth a flip in the dip, ....snip
>
> Doug,
> Nice write-up.  My only comment is that the phrase 'need a rudder' is not 
> helpful.  The rudder should be considered primarily an energy saving 
> device. Even in moderate conditions that can easily be handled without a 
> rudder, i.e., rudder not 'needed', some small percentage of energy can 
> often be saved by using the rudder and just paddling forward.  So why not?
> Jerry

Yes, absolutely - a rudder is an energy saving device. Interesting that in 
some locals where big seas are often the norm, rudder use tends to be high - 
as like down-under, Australia/New Zealand.

I don't remember saying "need a rudder" as much as "might" need a rudder; 
probably should have said "might benefit from a rudder." Anyway, doesn't 
really matter, as with most things kayak related, it's all a matter of 
degree. And those who love rudders will usually continue to do so and those 
who don't, won't.

For those that do, gas-style rudder pedders are a must in my book, as is a 
deep-draft rudder, efficient up/downhaul lines, robustness, leak-free 
routing, overstern configuration, and deployment only when needed - um, 
beneficial to energy saving. Don't forget routine maintenance.

I routed my left/right lines through plastic deck fittings from a Perception 
parts inventory, molded into the deck about 12 years ago. I see the new VCP 
Rapier uses this exact same system.

My wife wants a rudder on her kayak now, because she wants sea kayaking to 
be fun. For others, the fun of sea kayaking is doing it without a rudder. 
The point is, go have some fun.

And as for the percentage of energy saving, don't forget to factor in the 
expenditure of energy while one is cursing the lack of a rudder when having 
one would be nice, and the cost associated with high blood pressure 
medication. :-)

I remember reading a trip report is Sea Kayaker magazine, written by the 
actual editor, Christopher Cunningham - a fantastic paddler in his own 
right. He was sorely missing the inclusion of a rudder on his borrowed 
touring kayak somewhere in the Mediterranean, I think it was. Not sure if 
the boat was a bum design, or what though. Ah, to rudder or not to rudder, 
that is the question. Regardless, learn to "rudder" with your paddle first.

Doug L 
***************************************************************************
PaddleWise Paddling Mailing List - Any opinions or suggestions expressed
here are solely those of the writer(s). You must assume the entire
responsibility for reliance upon them. All postings copyright the author.
Submissions:     PaddleWise_at_PaddleWise.net
Subscriptions:   PaddleWise-request_at_PaddleWise.net
Website:         http://www.paddlewise.net/
***************************************************************************